Medicare

Medical Monday: Delayed Edition

POLICY NEWS 

Midwife measuring blood pressure of a pregnant woman.jpg

The Department of Health and Human Services wants to expand funding for “ natural family planning” and “ fertility awareness” which are largely ineffective methods of timing based birth control. In other words, DHHS want Medicaid to begin covering visits where patients are told this is a viable method of contraception. In other words, the DHHS wants to spend your tax dollars on an ineffective, scientifically invalid method of birth control. Meanwhile the rest of the administration is working on dismantling the Contraceptive Mandate, the part of current insurance law which states that insurers must cover, without copay, real effective birth control. Additionally, the DHHS has announced it is moving away from “ comprehensive sexual education” which is evidence based, and instead will be using your tax dollars to teach “ abstinence only” which has been proven not to work. It is beginning to seem like the administration wants women to have more babies. Maybe they see this as stimulating the economy through having more consumers, I don’t know. 

California Judge Haywood Gilliam has stood up to the Feds determined to weaken the contraceptive mandate. He has blocked changes to the ACA in California, saying that he will not allow these changes “ transform contraceptive coverage from an entitlement to a benefit subject to employer discretion.”

Utah is writing law which will require radiologists to specifically notify women of dense breast tissue. In this warning they are to explain that screening is less effective, and that they may be eligible for other screening modalities. 

New Jersey has replaced Republican Governor Chris Christie with Democrat Phil Murphy. Governor Murphy has reversed 8 years of policy by restoring funding to Planned Parenthood and other women’s health organizations. He has also signed a bill expanding coverage for Medicaid coverage of family planning, prenatal care and cancer screening. 

DHHS is working on various plans to reduce the price of prescription drugs to consumers. Sounds good right ? However one of the cost control measures is capping the amount of prescription drug benefit that Medicare Recipients can receive. The other strategies include enabling as many as 5 states to collectively bargain with suppliers over prices. 

The administration is at it again, proposing bargain basement plans for people. In the words of Admiral Akbar, “It’s a trap !”

These plans are cheap, and some fear that consumers might not realize their limitations on coverage or pre-existing conditions. These plans which do not comply with the protections and coverage of the ACA ( Affordable Care Act) are a recipe for future disaster. They contribute little to the collective pot and cover little for their purchasers. 

 

MEDICAL NEWS 

In the important and alarming department, we have cleaning sprays. New research published in the American Journal or Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine has shown that the “regular use of cleaning sprays can have as much impact on health as smoking a pack of cigarettes a day." In this 6000 person study, “ cleaning even once per week was associated with an accelerated lung decline risk”. I will try to find out more about the types of cleaning agents used. 

HPV vaccine is still underused. Fewer than a third get their first dose by age 13, and fewer than half of all children are up to date on all their doses

In other vaccine news, a recent inventory of 400,000 births confirms that both influenza and TDaP vaccines are safe in pregnancy, and confer protection to both mom and baby. 

When we think of a heart attack, we think of an older man with check pain. However, women suffer heart attacks almost as much as men. However in women, particularly women under 55, symptoms may not be recognized since they are different than mens. These patients are more likely to have what is described as indigestion, shortness of breath, palpitations, or jaw pain. 

In related news, women’s heart attacks may have a different mechanism, coronary vasoconstriction, rather than the blockage from plaques that male patients often have. A new study confirms that among women with chest pain, and clean arteries, nearly 8% have scarred areas on the heart confirming that a heart attack occurred. 

About half of all breast cancer patient facing radiation heard “ frightening stories” about it. However after the therapy, only 2% agreed that the stories were true. 

Illinois has targeted maternal morbidity, specifically maternal morbidity due to severe maternal hypertension. A “quality initiative” specifying a “suite of interventions” was implemented. Participants qualified for the study by having BP at or greater than 160/110 (yikes!). Interventions included prompt pharmacologic treatment of maternal hypertension, specifically designed discharge education, and short postpartum follow up intervals. Severe maternal morbidity such as stroke as already decreased by 41%.

 

Stay tuned for more exciting news from the world of Obstetrics and Gynecology right here, next week, on Medical Monday. 

Medical Monday: Breaking News from the World of Obstetrics and Gynecology

Policy News 

unhappy doctor with headache stressed holding coffee.jpg

The Trump Administration will continue to use a bundled payment model for Medicare recipients. This means that the government will pay a certain lump some to cover all the inpatient and procedure related medical care given to Medicare patient rendered in a 90 day period of time. If the healthcare providers use less than that amount of money they can receive a bonus. This strikes me as a terribly perverse incentive. Hospitals and caregivers have every incentive to skimp on care so they can pocket the bonus. What if the amount of money allocated is not enough for all the care the patient needs within the 90 days? It is interesting to note that this bundled payment strategy was created under Obamacare (The Affordable Care Act or the ACA) and has been reincarnated in almost exactly the same form under the Trump administration.

Several women’s health organizations including the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), have instituted a program called"The Care Women Deserve”. Under this program, there will be an effort to educate all women regarding the health services to which, under the ACA which is current law, they are entitled, at little or no cost. Examples of these services include well woman visits, also known as annual exams, Pap smears, contraception, also known as birth control, HIV screening, mammograms and breast-feeding support. Not all women know that they are entitled to all these services.

The Trump administration has long tried to weaken the contraceptive mandate, the part of the Affordable Care Act which requires insurance companies to cover contraception without co-pay. They have received many legal challenges to these attempts. The Trump administration has paid out over 3 million dollars of taxpayer money to to settle these lawsuits.

For the first time in Medicaid's 50 year history certain states will be allowed to interpose work requirements on certain able bodied adult recipients. The National Health Law Center is preparing to challenge this in court.

Washington DC’s only pubic hospital has been closed due to quality concerns. 

The Wall Street Journal is reporting that the GOP is scaling back plans to reform the ACA and social security type programs. They are focusing on basic problems like funding the government. They are even talking about increasing the debt limit and reaching a compromise on immigration. Since when has the GOP been interested in increasing the debt limit ? 

 

Medical News 

Studies 

  • Once again our own immune system is at the heart of a disease process. Evidence from a mice model suggests that the damage caused from Zika virus infection is actually from the mother’s immune response against the virus in the baby. This was published in Science Immunology. 
  • A large retrospective study has indicated that pregnant women who take methylphenidate for ADHD have a higher likelihood of having a baby with a heart defect. 
  •  A new study published in the Journal Birth looks again at Texas maternal mortality rates. Between 2011 and 2015, there has been an 87% spoke in maternal mortality. The worst has been in mothers over, 40 with that group having a mortality rate 27 times that of women under 40. This is felt to be related to increasing rates on chronic and under treated disease including obesity, lack of insurance and lack of health care. 
  • A 172 woman study published in Menopause made the we-already-knew-this-department. They have shown that one year of postmenopausal hormone therapy prevented depressive symptoms more effectively than placebo. Postmenopausal hormone therapy is FDA approved for hot flashes and vaginal dryness, but not for mood disturbance. Maybe it should be. 
  • The Journal of Asthma has published a study linking prenatal exposure to PCBs ( polychlorinated biphenyls) to asthma and upper respiratory infections and eczema in children. 
  • A new study has indicated that women who work night shifts have a (gasp) 19% higher chance of getting cancer than those who do not work at night. This meta-analysis has shown that the risk is proportional to time worked at night, and that the risks  go up differently for different cancers. The most surprising is skin cancer with a 41% increase in risk. Next is a 32% increase in breast cancer, and an 18% increased risk in digestive cancers. Yikes ! I hope the exact reasons for this get figured out and dealt with ! 

We have a new department ! It is called the stupid and irresponsible department. Our inaugural feature is devoted to the TV show Black Mirror, whose writers decided to depict emergency contraction, aka “ Plan B” or “ the morning after pill” quite incorrectly. In particular, they portrayed a teen who took it as having nausea, which is not typical. A nurse in the show informs her she had taken it “ to terminate a pregnancy”. Basically the show confused the morning after pill with the abortion pill. The morning after pill is progesterone only, thus should not cause nausea. Plan B does not cause abortion of an established pregnancy. It prevents pregnancy. Thanks so much, TV,  thanks. 

Stay tuned for more exciting news from the world of Obstetrics and Gynecology next week here, on Medical Monday. 

 

Medical Monday: Delayed Edition

Young pregnant woman receiving vaccination in clinic.jpg

Policy has marched on, despite my delay. Last week, the Graham Cassidy Bill to replace the Medicaid Expansion with State Block grants fell with a thud without even being brought to a vote. This is because it did not even have enough Republican support. 

Early in the week, the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services resigned amidst constroversy. He was criticized for his extensive use of taxpayer funded charter flights. He was, by those in the medical community, not considered to be a friend of health care. He was viewed as a political appointee there to tow the party line. 

Most recently, Senator Bernie Sanders has revealed that this administration has been giving consideration to cutting Medicare as well as Medicaid. Medicare is the Federal Health Insurance Program for the elderly and the disabled, which Medicaid is the health insurance program for the poorest sector. Democrats allege these cuts in health care for vulnerable populations would be used to finance tax cuts “for the rich”. 

Premium prices for those purchasing health insurance through the ACA will most assuredly increase. Some increases will be more than 50%. This increase in cost of insurance premiums is NOT based on any definite information of federal subsidies reductions. Instead it is based on the THREAT of reduced or eliminated subsidy payments. Uncertainty and instability from the Federal government is causing insurers to raise prices, and is causing in insurance commissioners to allow them to do so. All premiums for all insurance plans are likely to rise. 

Prescription drug prices are likely to rise. The FDA (Food and Drug Administration) Commissioner Dr. Scott Gottleib, has declared that these high prices are a public health concern. In response, he has indicated a commitment to “more efficient generic drug development, review and approval”. 

Such uncertainty means hospitals and insurers will be unable to predict their income. This is causing them to take conservative positions across the board. This has also resulted in the closure of many rural hospitals, and the closure of maternity units within otherwise operational hospitals. More than half of all rural counties to not have a a prenatal clinic or Ob care facility. 

As discussed previously, several states have taken matters into their own hands. A red state, Utah, is fielding a proposal to expand access to birth control for low income women. Utah State Representative Ward has cited patient autonomy and cost savings as the driving benefits behind the bill. 

The morning after pill, widely considered in medical circles to be utterly safe, is now being dispensed from vending machines on certain college campuses. 

Massachusetts is considering a bill ensuring the provision of free birth control. This bill required the input of the third party payers, the insurance companies, as well as reproductive health advocates. It is expected to pass. 

In medical news, I am happy to announce the official eradication of infant and maternal tetanus. This infection once killed 10,000 newborns per year in the Western hemisphere. This has been at least in part due to the successful vaccination program using DPT in the past, and TDAP more recently. 

TDAP stands for tetanus, diphtheria, and acellular pertussis. Pertussis, also known as whooping cough, is a bad nuisance for healthy adults. However, it can be fatal in infants. All pregnant women are encouraged to get a TDAP booster in the third trimester. This turns out to confer 90% pertussis protection to the newborn. However, only half of all pregnant women got the vaccine. 

Confirmed: hormone containing IUDs do not adversely impact breastfeeding. A new study confirms what we would already expect. We expect this because hormone containing IUDs do not send hormone into the greater circulation; only to the lining of the uterus itself.  This is also the reason why they do not confer systemic side effects. 

In the bad news department, the CDC (Centers for Disease Control) report that sexually transmitted diseases are at record highs, for a second year in a row. This includes Chlamydia, gonorrhea, and syphilis. This is attributed to budget cuts impacting screening and treatment clinics but also to better testing methods. Chladmydia is soaring in women, while syphilis is most prominently increasing in gay and bisexual men. 

Much needed increased attention is being paid to post partum depression. I attended a conference today where it was highlighted that depression in this case is really a misnomer. The most common presentation of postpartum depression is anger or anxiety. A new study highlights that post partum depression is 27-47 times more likely to recur in a patient who has had it once. Postpartum depression has good treatments. More awareness and aggressive screening in the early post partum period is our best defense. 

Now we are up to date ! Stay tuned for more exciting news from the world of Obstetrics and Gynecology , here, next week, on Medical Monday.